If you get nervous about speaking, it’s tempting to look for a quick fix, and AI tools make that easy. Practice with a AI helper, get some feedback, repeat until the nerves go away. Simple, right?
I wish it was that simple. For some people, this can work. For others, it’s not going to relieve the anxiety.
When AI Can Help
If your anxiety comes from feeling like you haven’t practiced enough, and only that, then yes, AI can help. An AI tool gives you a place to rehearse, repeat, and get feedback whenever you want. For that kind of anxiety, more practice really is the answer.
The problem is that this is rarely the cause.
Why Practice Rarely Fixes Anxiety
Most anxiety about speaking is rooted in fear of some kind. You have to find the root and address it, and more practice or better delivery tips won’t do that. A fear of being judged isn’t solved by smoother transitions. A bad experience from the past isn’t erased by running your slides one more time.
In fact, continuing to practice while feeling nervous every time just rehearses the nerves. (I’ve written about overcoming the fear of being judged while speaking, and it’s a good place to start if that’s your fear.)

The First Question I Ask: “What Are You Afraid Of?”
Before we do anything else, I ask my clients who are battling nerves one question: “What are you afraid of?” You have to identify the fear before you can do anything about it, and no amount of practice will do this.
Sometimes the answer is not what the person expected.
The Client Who Thought She Was Underprepared
I worked with a client who noticed that she froze up and became anxious whenever one particular person was in the room. It took her a while to figure that out. She had assumed she was just underprepared.
What was really going on was a story she was telling herself about not being good enough. That person had made a negative comment in the past, and she’d let it get to her. Over time, she had built a story around how she was’nt a good speaker. Part of the work was changing that story. She also came to see that this person wasn’t an expert on speaking, so she didn’t need to treat their criticism as the final word.
No amount of extra practice would have found that. There was nothing wrong with her preparation.
The Zoom vs. In-Person Clue
Another pattern I see a lot: someone who tells me they’re fine in person but not on Zoom, or vice versa. When that happens, I know something else is going on. If you have the skills and can deliver in one format, those skills don’t vanish in the other. An underlying problem needs to be addressed.
I’m working with a client like this right now, who is fine in person but not on Zoom. The causes tend to be different depending on which setting is hard:
- Zoom only: Often it’s that you can’t see the other people’s reactions, so you can’t tell whether what you’re saying is landing.
- In person only: Often it’s the feeling that people are watching you, which brings out a fear of judgment more than Zoom does. On Zoom, it’s easier to hide the people you’re afraid of.
Same skills, different fear. An app measuring your pace and giving you feedback on the number of fillers you’re speaking can’t tell the difference.
The Biggest Change: Feeling in Control
The thing that seems to make the biggest difference for my clients is helping them feel in control. What that means is different for each person. It might be:
- Control of the narrative. Projecting the image you want to be perceived as, building the reputation you want so you aren’t judged negatively.
- Control over your words. So you don’t stumble or ramble, and you sound more articulate.
- Control over negative thoughts. Catching them before they spiral and you get stuck in your head.
- Control over the physical symptoms of nerves. Your body’s response to nerves doesn’t have to run the show.
- Control over the story you’re telling yourself. Like the client above, you can rewrite it.
These are the parts of anxiety an app doesn’t touch.
Advice That Backfires
I see a lot of people trying to fix anxiety on their own and running into the same traps:
Avoidance
Many people avoid speaking for as long as they possibly can. It works until it doesn’t, and by then they have no choice. That’s usually when they come to me, with a deadline and a lot more pressure than if they’d started sooner.
Forced Positive Thinking
Common internet advice is to repeat positive mantras or to tell yourself your nerves are really excitement. For intelligent adults, it feels like lying to yourself. Nobody who’s struggling can convince themselves “I am a really good public speaker” just by repeating it. And if you’re nervous, you know you’re nervous. Calling it excitement doesn’t help, because it feels inauthentic, and it often backfires.
Fixating on Filler Words
Trying to stamp out every “um” and “uh” puts pressure on you, and that pressure can make you more anxious. (If you’re doing this, here’s how to stop saying “um” and “uh” without making it worse.)
Practicing While Nervous
If you keep practicing and feeling nervous every time, that doesn’t make the nerves go away. It makes them familiar.
A First Step You Can Take This Week
You don’t need a coach or an app for this one. Try two things:
- Visualize success. Picture yourself succeeding. See the possibility of it going well.
- Make your self-talk neutral. Instead of mantras or “I’m going to fail,” just say, “I’ll do my best.”
Neutral works because it’s believable. You aren’t asking yourself to pretend, and you aren’t predicting a disaster.
When You Need More Than an App
If your anxiety has a root, whether it’s a fear of judgment, a bad past experience, or a story you tell yourself, you need someone who can help you get at it. That’s something a person can do and a tool can’t. If you want to compare the two, I wrote a side-by-side look at an AI public speaking coach vs. a human coach and a post on whether AI can replace a public speaking coach.
Curious what working together looks like? Here’s what to expect in your first public speaking coaching session, including where I start when nerves are the issue.
If nerves are holding you back, explore my coaching programs or book a free consultation and let’s find out what you’re really afraid of.
